Subaru Enthusiasts Car Club of the Sierras

Subaru Enthusiasts Car Club of the Sierras (https://www.seccs.org/forums/index.php)
-   General Subaru Discussion & Club Chat (https://www.seccs.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   SDRs or Formels? (https://www.seccs.org/forums/showthread.php?t=59)

ArthurS 2003-02-13 04:50 PM

I have yet to decide it I will get those springs. I am pretty sure I will, but they are ORANGE :roll: .....But I guess that doesn't matter to much.

I am getting these things from SubyDude:

*Either of these rims haven't fully decdied:
Rota SDR's Silver 17x7.5
Rota Formels Royal 17x7.5
*Tanabe GF Springs (Possibly)
*Sti High-pressure cap (Everyone sells um, I decided to get one)
*Sti Blank key
*Chrome Spline lug nuts w/key

That will be enough for one purchase.

sperry 2003-02-13 04:51 PM

Hey post some pics of those rims... I don't remember the Formels. I do now the SDRs are hot tho...

ArthurS 2003-02-13 04:55 PM

Yea the SDR's are pretty cool. I am really torn between the two. They are both good deals also.

Here is the link to the Formels:


http://www.rotawheels.com/formel.htm

sperry 2003-02-13 04:57 PM

Ahh... now I see why you're torn... those Formels are super nice too... very classy...

hehe, I think it's quarter flipping time...

ArthurS 2003-02-13 05:05 PM

Pretty much. The Formels are about 25$ cheaper per wheel, so 100$ total. Thats why I am leaning towards them. Either way, I will have a set by the end of the month. They won't have tires on them, but Ill have them.

Where is Tirerack located? I have to swing by there once I get the rims to have them put on Kuhmo's and install the springs....(unless you per chance know how to install springs 8) )

sperry 2003-02-13 05:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
Pretty much. The Formels are about 25$ cheaper per wheel, so 100$ total. Thats why I am leaning towards them. Either way, I will have a set by the end of the month. They won't have tires on them, but Ill have them.

Where is Tirerack located? I have to swing by there once I get the rims to have them put on Kuhmo's and install the springs....(unless you per chance know how to install springs 8) )

Tirerack is located almost across the street from Summitt out in Sparks. I'm not sure they do tire installs unless you're buying a rim/tire package from them.. you might wanna call and ask. The place is just a warehouse really, not much of a customer service area.

I've done some spring installs on Austin's mustang with him before. It was a bit of a PITA, but the WRX should be easier. All you gotta do is rent a spring compressor, and then go to town on it... put the car on jackstands, compress the stock spring, unbolt the strut, take the strut off, then reinstall with the new spring... but having never done it, I'm not sure how hard it'll be.

I'm planning on (someday...) getting some take-off STi struts and springs... since they came off a car, they're ready to just bolt on, top hats and all. But that's like 3 times the cost of springs alone.

ArthurS 2003-02-13 05:34 PM

True they may not do the install. I will call them. If not I might see if my friend at Good Year can hook me up and install them.

I read a Review over Nasioc about those Kuhmo's Escta MX's and most people said they wern't worth the money and just just the 712's (?) or whatever the other ones are.

Since this will be my first auto-x season, I should probably go with some cheaper tires anyway.

AtomicLabMonkey 2003-02-14 09:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sperry
I've done some spring installs on Austin's mustang with him before. It was a bit of a PITA, but the WRX should be easier. All you gotta do is rent a spring compressor, and then go to town on it... put the car on jackstands, compress the stock spring, unbolt the strut, take the strut off, then reinstall with the new spring... but having never done it, I'm not sure how hard it'll be.

Actually since I've learned more about my suspension and watched Mike Maier work on the car, you can take out the springs on my car without a spring compressor... you have to disconnect the swaybars and things from the control arms, but basically once you have the chassis on jackstands you can put a jack under the control arm and slowly lower it down until the spring is totally unloaded. Then you just work it out of the seat with your hands. He can take one out in like 10 minutes, as opposed to the whole weekend we spent doing it down in San Luis. :)

sperry 2003-02-14 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AtomicLabMonkey
Quote:

Originally Posted by sperry
I've done some spring installs on Austin's mustang with him before. It was a bit of a PITA, but the WRX should be easier. All you gotta do is rent a spring compressor, and then go to town on it... put the car on jackstands, compress the stock spring, unbolt the strut, take the strut off, then reinstall with the new spring... but having never done it, I'm not sure how hard it'll be.

Actually since I've learned more about my suspension and watched Mike Maier work on the car, you can take out the springs on my car without a spring compressor... you have to disconnect the swaybars and things from the control arms, but basically once you have the chassis on jackstands you can put a jack under the control arm and slowly lower it down until the spring is totally unloaded. Then you just work it out of the seat with your hands. He can take one out in like 10 minutes, as opposed to the whole weekend we spent doing it down in San Luis. :)

On a WRX, the spring is not compressed by the control arm.. it's compressed by the strut... The whole strut/spring assembly can come out of the car, still compressed. You could try to take off the top hat w/o compressing the spring, but when that last bolt comes off, the top hat'll prolly take your head off... BOINOINOINOING!! :lol: Also, you'll never get a new spring on w/o compressing it IIRC.

sperry 2003-02-19 03:42 PM

Hey Art... here's a good pic of the SDRs on a Black Wagon:

http://www.digitalpose.com/mbr/1/138...2840098_vl.jpg

Looks pretty sick!! But I'm still torn about the formels... they would rock too. I think you're in a win-win situation!

ArthurS 2003-02-19 04:23 PM

Yea its driving me nuts too. All my friends are seperated on the issue also.

I am leaning a little towards the Formels still, but keep looking at the SDR's. GOD.......I should just buy them both :lol: :lol:

NExt question: I don't want the brake calipers I have on now to look like crap once I get the 17's. So its either I replace them with aftermarket ones (blue preferably) or paint them. http://www.fastwrx.com/brakcalpaink.html. Do you know of any companies that produce GOOD blue or red brake calipers?

I did want to buy a big break kit eventually, but those are so damn expensive. So I will just get the parts one by one.

sperry 2003-02-19 04:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
Yea its driving me nuts too. All my friends are seperated on the issue also.

I am leaning a little towards the Formels still, but keep looking at the SDR's. GOD.......I should just buy them both :lol: :lol:

NExt question: I don't want the brake calipers I have on now to look like crap once I get the 17's. So its either I replace them with aftermarket ones (blue preferably) or paint them. http://www.fastwrx.com/brakcalpaink.html. Do you know of any companies that produce GOOD blue or red brake calipers?

I did want to buy a big break kit eventually, but those are so damn expensive. So I will just get the parts one by one.

The color of the brake pads doesn't matter, since you can't really see them under the calipers. Any hi-temp (like the 900 deg stuff you linked to) paint should work for brake calipers, but you have to be careful painting them, so you get he paint only where is should go.

BTW: do you have weight info on the SDRs vs the Formels?

AtomicLabMonkey 2003-02-19 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS

NExt question: I don't want the brake calipers I have on now to look like crap once I get the 17's. So its either I replace them with aftermarket ones (blue preferably) or paint them. http://www.fastwrx.com/brakcalpaink.html. Do you know of any companies that produce GOOD blue or red brake calipers?

Just worry about the quality of the calipers and how they'll fit into the brake system you eventually want to build... brake components have to be fairly carefully matched to one another or it'll throw the overall system out of whack and you won't have good brake performance or feel. The best performing (read: expensive) brakes are usually whole kits for good reason.. if the company is worth anything, like Baer, Brembo, etc.., then they've matched all the components together and tested it as a complete system. Plus, you want to make sure if you get new calipers that they can accomodate bigger rotors if you want to do that down the road. So just worry about how it'll work, not about how it looks... if it doesn't make the car go (or stop) faster, it's not really worth getting anyway. :wink:

sperry 2003-02-19 04:55 PM

Lots of good points...

Unless you're gonna track the car, the WRX brakes are very good, and cen be made virtually fade-free w/ the right bits.

- Pads: I'm using Axxis Ultimates. They rock!
- Lines: Stainless Steel = less pedal mush, I got Goodridges.
- Fluid: Motul 600 gets high praise, but I haven't tried it... I'm running Ford 550F fluid... it's really affordable, and seems to work pretty good.

My setup does pretty well. I've worn the hell outta my pads and my rotors are half gone since autocrossing on the stock pads grooved them to hell, and they had to be resurfaced to just above the min width. I've got a set of StopTech slotted rotors in the stock size waiting to go on the front come spring.

Read some of Gary Sheenan's posts on NASIOC. That guy runs the USTCC WRX. He's found that the above setup (pads, lines, fluid) is even good enuf for occational track use!

When you start going to big brake kits, you have to make sure they're matched to the car. Some people get giant Brembos on the front and back and they can't out brake a stock WRX cuz the front's were designed to work with the stock WRX rears.

The StopTech and Subaru FHI front kits are supposed to work well with the stock rears and master cylinder, but they're like $1000.

ArthurS 2003-02-19 05:14 PM

Hey,

I guess I might actually just look into some colored calipers. I have seen some people with some nice black ones..WILWOOD or some other brand.

ROTA SDR's and FORMELS are both 16.3 lbs. At least I know how much the SDR's weigh, not sure about the formels...but ROTA seems to keep the weight consistant.

AtomicLabMonkey 2003-02-19 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sperry

- Fluid: Motul 600 gets high praise, but I haven't tried it... I'm running Ford 550F fluid... it's really affordable, and seems to work pretty good.

One thing to note: The Motul is supposed to be great, but I believe it is a racing fluid, and in general with Motul or Castrol, etc. racing brake fluids they absorb moisture from any air they come into contact with very quickly. This tends to mean that you'll have to bleed the brakes fairly often to get rid of a spongy brake pedal.. so unless you want to be doing that every week or two it's probably not adviseable for your street car.

sperry 2003-02-19 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
Hey,

I guess I might actually just look into some colored calipers. I have seen some people with some nice black ones..WILWOOD or some other brand.

ROTA SDR's and FORMELS are both 16.3 lbs. At least I know how much the SDR's weigh, not sure about the formels...but ROTA seems to keep the weight consistant.

Don't just buy calipers! (read LabMonkey's post... he's the Mechanical Engineer) Buy a whole kit, if you're gonna go bigger. Otherwise, painting the stock calipers is no big deal, and looks good too. Just getting calipers not specifically designed for the stock rotors/master cylinder/etc would prolly cost like $600, and make the braking worse. The $40 can of paint's a much better deal.

I know that Rota rims vary in weight quite a bit. 17" Attacks are about 15lbs, 18" SubZeros are about 16lbs, SDRs are 16.3 as you say, but I've seen the 16" Formel listed at 17.7lbs!!

http://www.wheelspecs.com/specs/wheelmodels/344

sperry 2003-02-19 05:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AtomicLabMonkey
Quote:

Originally Posted by sperry

- Fluid: Motul 600 gets high praise, but I haven't tried it... I'm running Ford 550F fluid... it's really affordable, and seems to work pretty good.

One thing to note: The Motul is supposed to be great, but I believe it is a racing fluid, and in general with Motul or Castrol, etc. racing brake fluids they absorb moisture from any air they come into contact with very quickly. This tends to mean that you'll have to bleed the brakes fairly often to get rid of a spongy brake pedal.. so unless you want to be doing that every week or two it's probably not adviseable for your street car.

That's just the thing.. lots of street bike guys, and I-Club dudes run Motul, and say it's great, and doesn't absorb water too bad... Which is why it's so bank: racing performance, street maintence... but never having ponied up and tried it, that's all heresay.

ArthurS 2003-02-19 05:41 PM

Your right. And the 17.7lbs is for the 16" rim and no the 17" Formel. That means the 17" is even heavier. I am probably going to go SDR now, plus I can get those through subydude now. The formels I would have to get from somewhere else. (he doesn't stock them).

As for the big break kit issue, if I get a big-break kit, then I can't use 16" wheels with it. I plan on using the stock rims during winter. So if I were to do that, then I would have to replace the whole big break assembly in the winter?

sperry 2003-02-19 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
Your right. And the 17.7lbs is for the 16" rim and no the 17" Formel. That means the 17" is even heavier. I am probably going to go SDR now, plus I can get those through subydude now. The formels I would have to get from somewhere else. (he doesn't stock them).

As for the big break kit issue, if I get a big-break kit, then I can't use 16" wheels with it. I plan on using the stock rims during winter. So if I were to do that, then I would have to replace the whole big break assembly in the winter?

Some 16" rims fit over big brake kits... but not the stockers. It would be easier to drop the money on 17" winter rims... some Rota Tarmacs or something than to swap brakes twice a year... At least to me, $500 is worth not having to take off my brakes. 'Course, I'm plenty happy with the stock sized brakes, and that includes autocrossing!

ArthurS 2003-02-20 03:21 PM

I think if I just paint the caipers, then I can hold myself over. Brakes seem like a big investment, when they are already pretty good. I would rather put it into vishnu.

sperry 2003-02-20 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
I think if I just paint the caipers, then I can hold myself over. Brakes seem like a big investment, when they are already pretty good. I would rather put it into vishnu.

Yeah, that's prolly the best plan. I even think the calipers aren't that bad stock... kinda gold-ish.

(BTW: good to see doink's server is back up... It wasn't my fault!!)

ArthurS 2003-02-20 03:34 PM

SSsssuuuuuurrreee it wasn't.

Well my calipers are actually kinda green/puke color, since I cleaned my wheel about a month ago with some of that foam wheel stuff and it got on the caliper. It then must have dyed it or something, but its a odd color now.

sperry 2003-02-20 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
SSsssuuuuuurrreee it wasn't.

Well my calipers are actually kinda green/puke color, since I cleaned my wheel about a month ago with some of that foam wheel stuff and it got on the caliper. It then must have dyed it or something, but its a odd color now.

Freaky... copper oxidation? Austin, drop some materials knowledge!

ArthurS 2003-02-21 10:06 AM

Hey,

Here is a link to a bunch of pics with the ROTA Formels on a WRB sedan.

http://forums.nasioc.com/forums/show...hlight=formels

THEY ALSO COME IN GOLD!!!!!!!!

sperry 2003-02-21 10:09 AM

Holy crap!

Man, if those Formels came in 18" gold, I'd sell my SubZeros and get some!!

ArthurS 2003-02-21 10:13 AM

I know. They look sick. I am trying to find a set of Golds on a car, but it seems no one has put them on yet. I am going to talk to Oakos Automotive http://oakos.com/ and see if they can get the gold in for me.

If they can, I might deal with the extra pounds on the rim. Someone mentioned in another thread that the 17's only weight around 17.8.

ArthurS 2003-02-26 04:31 PM

:x Looks like I may be going SDR's since everyone is selling out of the Formels with polished lip.

Oh well, SDR's still look damn good IMO.

ArthurS 2003-03-11 05:38 PM

Question:

Carson Subaru said that once you get bigger rims and tires, that your speedometer goes off. It will show that you are going faster then you actually are and would need to be adjusted. Is this true? They said they aren't aloud to do it there either way, so that makes me feel like the aren't trying to just sell me. Have any of you with rims adjusted this?

sperry 2003-03-11 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
Question:

Carson Subaru said that once you get bigger rims and tires, that your speedometer goes off. It will show that you are going faster then you actually are and would need to be adjusted. Is this true? They said they aren't aloud to do it there either way, so that makes me feel like the aren't trying to just sell me. Have any of you with rims adjusted this?

It has to do with the overall diameter of the wheel, not just the rim. If you go to a larger rim, but have a lower profile tire, the overall diameter changes very little. This is called "plus-sizing" your rims. If you look at the tire rack specs for each tire, the last column is the revolutions per mile (or something). As long as this number is pretty close (like +/- 10) you won't notice any issues with your speedo or odo.

When I put rims on my TBird, the overall diameter of my tires was almost an inch smaller. This gave the car better acceleration, but caused my speedo to read lower than my actualy speed. Austin did the math for me.. it was something like 70mph on the speed0 = 65 in real life, and 105 on the speedo (the speed limiter) was only 95 in real life.

I am actually planning on reducing my overall diameter when I get some autocross rims and tires, since that will help the acceleration of the car. Remember, on AWD cars, all 4 tires *must* have the same overall diameter or you'll cook a differential or two! So, no mixing and matching tires unless they're the same size!

One more thing, if you were to get bigger rims, and keep the same profile on the tire, say a 225/65/17 or something, it would simply be too big to fit under the wheel well. :lol:

One more, one more thing... Carson *sells* cars with aftermarket rims.. I saw a few WRXs with Prodrive P7s on the lot when I was in there a year+ ago for my clutch replacement, so I dunno wtf they're talking about with the "we can't do rims" thing.

edit: Oh, I get it, they can't adjust the odometer... yeah there's laws against that... the speed sensor is linked to the odometer, so "adjusting" it is against the law to prevent odometer fraud.

ArthurS 2003-03-11 05:54 PM

No they said they would be happy to help with the rims, they just can't adjust the speedometer if the rims, like you said, create to bad of a offset. They said I would have to go to a shop or something.

Well, I plan on getting ROTA's, 17" x 7.5" and the Kuhmo ESCTA Supra 712's , but I forgot the siz the recommended. 215/75/17 or something like that.

AtomicLabMonkey 2003-03-12 08:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sperry
I am actually planning on reducing my overall diameter when I get some autocross rims and tires, since that will help the acceleration of the car.

Yeah, like Scott said the overall diameter of your tires is part of the overall gear ratio between the engine and where the rubber meets the road. Reducing the overall diameter gives you a shorter (numerically higher) ratio, and increasing it gives a taller (numerically lower) ratio. So if you put some bling bling 20"s on the car or something and the overall tire diameter goes from 25" to 28" for example, then the car is gonna accelerate slower. Just something to think about when buying rims/tires since we usually want the cars to go faster instead of slower. So just throw some teeny little 10" diameter rims on there and you'll be super-fast, hehe. :lol:

sperry 2003-03-12 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArthurS
Well, I plan on getting ROTA's, 17" x 7.5" and the Kuhmo ESCTA Supra 712's , but I forgot the siz the recommended. 215/75/17 or something like that.

Stock re-92's are 205/55-16's (829 revs per mile)

The tires for a Subaru on a 17x7.5 rim should be 225/45-17 (829 revs per mile). This is known as "+1 sizing" your rim. One inch bigger rim diameter, same overall diameter.

I'll be getting 235/40-17's (840 revs per mile) for autocross, since they'll be a bit wider, and a little quicker. I'm not sure that 235's will fit on a wagon since the wagon doesn't have the fender flares.

dknv 2003-03-12 09:49 AM

tire / rotation calculation
 
My bf showed me this website last year when I was tire shopping ---

http://www.miata.net/garage/tirecalc.html

Enlightening.

ZER026D 2003-03-12 10:09 AM

I have heard that on the sedan we can use up to 245 with a little rolling of the fenders I think I might go for it.

sperry 2003-03-12 02:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZER026D
I have heard that on the sedan we can use up to 245 with a little rolling of the fenders I think I might go for it.

Good luck, you're going to have to roll the fenders ($500+ if there's any paint damage), install ride height adjustable coil-overs ($2000), and get very specifically sized rims, like Volk CE-28N's ($1600). So, expect to drop like $4000. Whereas you could get some 235's on Rotas for $1000, and not have to roll the fenders. Is that 1cm of width really worth $3000 and possibly having to paint the fenders?

Here's a pretty good discussion about running 245's and all the work required to get them to fit:

http://forums.nasioc.com/forums/show...hreadid=282620

But it can be done, with minor rubbing:
http://66.123.66.130/dussandersTires...s/DSC00005.jpg


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:57 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All Content Copyright Subaru Enthusiasts Car Club of the Sierras unless otherwise noted.