Thanks for the comments, guys. It's really frustrating and disappointing to see a car with only $20k miles taking a good bit of damage like that.
I've turned up Chargespeed and Zerosports, and thanks for the heads up on Do-Luck. Do-Luck and Chargespeed seem to look pretty good to me. I'm less excited about this Zerosports look:
http://www.z1auto.com/prodmore.asp?m...ior&prodid=595
It's been really difficult to find some solid discussions and lists of different bumpers. It's also been tough to locate anyone selling the OEM bumper (preferably the STI bumper since it seems to have some additional downforce on the stock WRX bumper) to get some pricing on that for comparison's sake. I also think I prefer having fog lights.
This site has all 3 bumpers for comparison (and there is indeed a wide variety of pricing)
http://www.rallysportdirect.com/shop.../21_26_134_163